One of the many things on my to-do list is to change my primary e-mail address and provider.
I’ve been at my current address for almost a quarter of the century. It’s on a system administered by some friends of mine, which is a remnant of the days when it was kinda hard to get e-mail addresses that weren’t tied to an ISP. People tended to change ISPs somewhat regularly back then, and even back then changing addresses was a pain. (Ironically, I’ve been with my current ISP for about as long, but I didn’t know that at the time.)
While I have a few reasons I want to make this change, a larger one is that none of us is getting any younger, and if they were to get hit by a bus or decide to get out of the business of running the server, then I might have to move very quickly. I also suspect that very few people are still using this system for their primary e-mail, which doesn’t seem like a great spot for me to be (the main person they’re supporting the e-mail for). I am grateful to my friends that I’ve been able to use this server for a long time, but it feels like it’s time to switch.
The problem is that finding a new provider is hard.
I know that I don’t want to go with one of the big free e-mail providers, Apple, Microsoft or (ugh) Google. I actually do use my Apple iCloud e-mail for some important things, but I don’t want it to be my primary e-mail for everything, or even for most things.
I’m not looking for super-secure e-mail because, well, it’s e-mail, and unless you’re doing fancy encryption (which I think almost no one does) it’s not very secure by its nature. But it’s still been hard to decide where to go.
I asked around about a year ago and got several enthusiastic recommendations for Fastmail. So it’s probably in the lead. The most commonly recommended client for secure e-mail is Proton, although the shine is off of them recently due to reports of their CEO pushing engineers to use AI more aggressively. Another secure candidate is Tuta.
Searching around it’s hard to find evidence to make a decision. All of these sites have their proponents, and especially for Proton you will see people on Reddit (yeah I know… Reddit) saying not to fall for the panic around Proton and AI.
Additionally, I do my web hosting and domain named through Dreamhost. but I have found their e-mail systems to be a little flaky in the past. It’s been a while since I’ve really tried to use them, though.
I think my criteria for a new provider are these:
- Must work with Apple’s macOS and iOS mail clients via IMAP. (Dreamhost’s system has been wonky here in the past. And Microsoft Outlook doesn’t work with IMAP on macOS.)
- Must be reliable.
- Must not just suddenly disappear out from under me if, for example, my credit card gets compromised and I miss a payment. (I’ve heard that Fastmail will reclaim addresses quickly. I don’t know if this is a risk there.)
One thing that’s often recommended is to set up a custom domain for my own e-mail, which I know many people do, because then you own it, and can redirect it to another provider if necessary. As I said I have a couple of domains through Dreamhost (including this one!), and hypothetically I could set up one of them to route to Fastmail, and then I could set up whatever addresses I want under the domain. One thing I worry about is the domain going away (e.g., if Dreamhost goes under or somehow it doesn’t get renewed). And then I don’t really want to have to fiddle with these sorts of configurations, but hopefully it would be a “set it up and then never worry about it again” scenario.
(Aside: I actually have had a domain for a while that I want to move this blog to, and would also want to use it for my primary e-mail.)
Overall I guess I worry that the more moving parts I have the more risk there is. And of course losing my primary e-mail would be very, very bad. At least as bad as losing my mobile phone number.
I guess unless I want to go with one of the big tech providers there is just some level of risk here, even if it’s small. And maybe I should try setting it up (e.g., getting Fastmail and setting my custom domain at Dreamhost to use it as the e-mail service) and using it for a few less-critical sites to see how it works.
This is one of several things I would have tried to work through earlier this year if I hadn’t had all my mental energy for such projects dominated by managing my dad’s affairs. (And that’s still a mental drain for me, but I also can’t just leave stuff like this unhandled forever.) It feels like yet another thing where I think “Why can’t this be easy?”
Just another aspect of this capitalist hellscape we live in, I guess.